Do You Really Think Following a WFPB Diet is a Radical Way to Lose Weight?

 

A common reaction many overweight or obese people have upon learning about a Whole Food Plant Based (WFPB) diet is that it is a radical method to lose weight. It seems that the reasons for this reaction are the same reasons that make a WFPB diet effective as the healthiest way to lose weight and keep it off.

Transitioning to a WFPB diet is a systemic change that treats the cause of chronic disease. This systemic change requires a lifelong effort on the part of a client or patient. For many people, the change seems so monumental; they have doubts that they can muster enough effort to meet the challenge.

In contrast, even though bariatric surgeries such as Laparoscopic Gastric Banding, Gastric Bypass and Sleeve Gastrectomies require following strict protocols pre and post surgery, these procedures are becoming more and more popular. I’ll never understand why people don’t consider procedures that disrupt or mutilate perfectly functioning organs as radical. Perhaps it’s because they concentrate on who they perceive is giving the most effort. The surgery is something the surgeon does – all the patient has to do is lie down.  They may not give enough thought to what is actually being done to their bodies and the post surgical effort required of them to maintain the weight that they lose.

It’s probably the same reason people will resort to taking drugs to help with weight loss. Although almost all weight loss drugs come with the disclaimer that the drug should be taken in conjunction with a healthy diet and regular exercise, this disclaimer is often written in such small font, it is barely visible. Popping a pill doesn’t take much effort so weight loss drugs can be very seductive.   So seductive, that people often ignore the many known side effects of these drugs.

In the case of Fen-Phen, a once very popular weight loss drug, heart valve damage was a side effect that was missed during the clinical testing of the drug.   Fen-Phen was eventually withdrawn from the market.

I recently saw an advertisement for a new weight loss drug called Belviq. Click here for the the two minute ad.   I can’t imagine that anyone in their right mind would think about taking this drug, but hundreds of thousands, if not millions will. It’s not because the majority of obese people seeing this ad will ask for this drug, but even a small percentage of viewers who decide to give the drug a try is a large number of people. Pharmaceutical companies have the means to reach millions of people, so it becomes a numbers game. Even the most successful WFPB promoters (ie Dr John McDougall, Dr Joel Fuhrman, Dr. Neal Barnard, Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn Jr, and others) don’t have the reach of pharmaceutical companies – not even close.

So the small percentage of people who don’t feel that taking Belviq is a radical method to lose weight will result in many people suffering one or more of the  side effects mentioned in the ad.   I find it especially troubling that heart valve problems were mentioned as a potential side effect. Could this be Fen-Phen all over again?

Unlike drugs and surgeries, the most likely side effect of weight loss from following a WFPB diet is a life of optimal health that is long-lasting and full-functioning. In other words – a Plantastic Life!

Comments

  1. Very well written Dominic! As you know, just in the practice I work in patients ask on a daily basis for a prescription for Belviq. They truly believe it will be the “answer” they are looking for. As for the different weight loss surgical procedures, I have witnessed first hand many complications people suffer as a result of these surgeries. There are some people that do lose a significant amount of weight after surgery without too many complications, but the majority of these people end up putting the weight back on.

    However, with our help, hopefully people will become educated on a WFPB diet, realize they can eat an abundance of the “right” foods, dramatically improve their health, and the side effect they can expect from following this lifestyle–their ULTIMATE GOAL–weight loss!!

  2. Beth Sterling says

    I have been WFPD since February and have not lost an ounce of weight! I started it for health reasons with the hope of weight loss as well. I have hoshimotos and since being WFPD I haven’t had to take thyroid meds. My acid reflux has also completely gone away. I do still have joint pain and stiffness, but the most frustrating is not losing ANY weight. Any suggestions would be much appreciated.

  3. I think you misunderstand how things work with bariatric surgery. It’s not that it’s becoming “more popular” — it’s about recognizing the impossibility for most obese people to lose any significant amount of weight and keep it off, regardless of one’s diet.

    Bariatric programs all require patients to do a heck of a lot of work on making lifestyle changes, of which diet is only one element, albeit an important one. The surgery is indeed “radical,” but it is never an easy way out or something taken for granted, or a substitute for lifestyle change. It is a tool. Check out what Dr. Garth Davis (WFPB doctor) has to say: https://www.facebook.com/drgarth/videos/bariatric-surgery-discussions-why-do-people-suffer-with-obesity/1606253332728902/

    Another thing to note is that the surgeries are now done laparoscopically, which makes them very safe — much safer than they used to be.

    I used to be dead set against bariatric surgery, believing it to be barbaric. However, having thoroughly researched it, I believe it is the only humane way to deal with a need for very significant weight loss when a patient is really struggling.

Speak Your Mind

*